The Wrong Twin by tiffanie K Evelyn Potter was the girl-who-lived, or so they thought. Harry was the true boy-who-lived, who beat Voldemort. After being dumped by Lily and James Potter, watch Harry Many changed but towards Alina Potter she is no longer Gryffindor but she is now a Slytherin thanks to the sorting hat. She find something about her inheritage it was br Unicorn's Blood by Noctus 1.
You have slain something pure and defenceless to save your Slytherin Pup by Eliza Paige Harry has always believed that he deserved the abuse that he recieved from his muggle, so when he got his Hogwarts letter he never said anything about the beatings. Dark by Alysha K 4.
Chaos and war had befallen the Wizarding World and there was little to no hope of saving it when Harry found himself back as a meek year-old boy once again and he vow I understand this topic has been analysed repeated and extrapolated on.
Nearly every conceivable conspiracy theory has been rolled out to…. The wizarding world has many inherent prejudices, the most notable of which is pureblood prejudice against muggleborns and squibs. On a…. Log in No account? Create an account. Remember me. Previous Share Flag Next. Perhaps I came at the question of Dumbledore's goodness or badness from a rather naive point of view: there appears to be a really large amount of debate as to whether Dumbledore is good, evil, or manipulative.
I've spent more time reading some of the work. I've been troubled by some of it; Dumbledore does seem a little "shady" at times, I've always thought that. But evil? Or even manipulative? Let's see if we can take a look at Albus Dumbledore's actions and see if we really do find a good, wise old wizard who occasionally makes a monumental mistake, rather than an evil old man who intentionally manipulates children.
Dumbledore under Scrutiny It's come to the point where we can possibly find as much conflicting evidence about Dumbledore's character as we can about Snape's - though we might want to say the Dumbledore side is weighted towards "good," and the Snape weighted towards "bad. We see things through Harry's eyes and experience. But we dare not turn that into a mandate to always conclude that if Harry believes it, it's probably wrong.
He was correct about Malfoy in Half-Blood Prince , was he not? It's just possible that Harry believes Dumbledore is a great wizard and hero, and that he is also right about that belief.
It's the Harry filter that most Evil! Dumbledore or Manipulative! Dumbledore are blaming for his good reputation. Dumbledore is Harry's hero, and he respects him; therefore we all love Dumbledore, and are blind to his faults. Codswallop, in my opinion. We can find just as much anger and disdain at Dumbledore through the Harry filter as we can awe and respect, and I might even argue that J.
Rowling intended to mis lead us to significant doubts about Dumbledore through the Harry filter with the end of Half-Blood Prince. This begs the question of how competent Dumbledore thought his own Order members were. Did he not think any of them capable of vengeance? The only reason Sirius survived that night in the Shack was because Lupin turned up and calmed everyone down and.
Dumbledore made these assumptions because he is used to being correct, he believes he knows people better than they know themselves.
I think this is a serious blind spot that Dumbledore really needs to watch out for. His pride, in some instances, makes him as bad as Voldemort. He waited years to make his move, too terrified to hear that he might have killed his own sister. I find this a really crippling weakness; Dumbledore gave his enemy leeway to destroy both him and the lives of countless others.
In this instance, Dumbledore betrayed stupidity: even if he did tell him that Dumbledore was the one who cast the final, fatal spell on Ariana, what reason did Grindelwald have to tell him the truth? Conclusion: If it came down to sheer firepower, Dumbledore has it all. Also welcome to the wiki!! I'm Chithra and I'm a proud Hufflepuff!! Hope you enjoy your time here and Happy Fandoming!! And Diya has already given you the links and guidelines, so you can refer to them!!
Moving this to the opinions category, and welcome! And yes, Dumbledore's sort of manipulative, but for good. Not evil Manipulative yes.
0コメント